Among the followers of Hahnemann we often hear the statement that homoeopathy is fundamental; that it is scientific; that it is based in natural law. Let us grant, for the sake of argument, that this is true, the natural corollary of this statement is that these laws must be active in all realms of fundamental science, i.e., that in those sciences that deal with the established laws of the universe the same natural laws must be active. It is self-evident that natural sympathy and cooperation; these laws are fixed and immutable. That which sets the planet in its orbit so regulates the other planets that they obey the same laws; their difference lies not in the governing laws but in time distance and circumstance, which is again ruled by law. If the planets moved at random, lawlessly, the result would be chaos.
So too if one realm of the universe was moved by fundamental laws which had no application or relation to other realms of the universe, the result must be chaos. If one science is seemingly governed by laws which are contradiction to those of another science, one must be lawless, not a science but chaos would be the result.
IF HOMOEOPATHY IS A FUNDAMENTAL SCIENCE, OR A PART OF A FUNDAMENTAL SCIENCE AS WE BELIEVE, IT MUST WORK IN HARMONY WITH ALL THE NATURAL REALMS, AND THE LAWS WHICH APPLY TO THOSE REALMS MUST APPLY ALSO, IN SOME DEGREE AND RELATIONSHIP, TO HOMOEOPATHY.
In spite of the years that have been devoted to the study of homoeopathy, with their accumulated data, we glimpse but dimly the possibilities of these conclusions.
When we realize the confusion that man has caused in his individual life, in very sphere, it is little wonder that he has misunderstood the natural powers and resources, and has failed to make use of natural laws. It is not strange, then, that medicine, among many other phases of our modern life, is but a series of experimental gropings without form or order.
The glimpse at our present state of social confusion cannot excuse our refusal to substantiate our claim that HOMOEOPATHY is based on natural laws. Let us consider the place HOMOEOPATHY must hold if our contentions be true.
If homoeopathy is founded upon fundamental laws. what are some of those laws? Our ignorance permits us to register but a few, but inevitably the time will come, if we keep a clear vision, when we will be able to add more to our burden of proof.
Let us look at the first formulated and recognized law of homoeopathy, SIMILIA SIMILIBUS CURANTUR. Whence came this law? It was simply an intelligent observation of our natural resource, those in their closest proximity to out daily lives, in the vegetable kingdom, and their relation to disturbed and disordered conditions arising in mankind himself. It was found that the ills of individual man could be successfully treated thus first doubtless these substances acted in an ordered and orderly manner under certain definite conditions and circumstances.
This recognition of law underlying cure is of ancient origin; no one knows when the first recognition of this law crept into use, but ancient Hindu manuscripts recorded its application. Certainly Aristotle recognized it, and Hippocrates sensed the possibilities of this law and applied it in some recorded cases. From time to time all through medical history this hypothesis was enunciated or demonstrated in greater or less degree. Hahnemann later demonstrated this law to be universal and not an occasional circumstance. He called the science and art of healing which naturally followed. Homoeopathy, but the thought was not a new one; it was age-old before a science of healing was based solely on this law.
In other words, in even the embryonic stages of homoeopathy it was found that law governed. Gradual experimentation widened the possibilities of application of these laws; no amount of experimentation extended the laws themselves. All that experimentation could do was to enlighten our minds regarding the scope of the law.
A law is a fundamental fact; because we do not recognize a law does not mean that the law does not exist. Even of man-made laws, which in their essence are not laws in the true sense but rules laid down by man for man, it is recognized that ignorance of the law is no excuse.
As observation became focused upon the unfolding of the law of cure, other regularities in reaction were discovered, and a second law of cure, this time pertaining to the direction of cure, was formulated. This was: CURE TAKES PLACE FROM, ABOVE DOWNWARD, FROM WITHIN OUTWARD, FROM AN IMPORTANT ORGAN TO A LESS IMPORTANT ORGAN; SYMPTOMS DISAPPEAR IN THE REVERSE ORDER OF THEIR APPEARANCE, THE FIRST TO APPEAR BEING THE LEAST TO DISAPPEAR.
Simple disappearance of symptoms is by no means cure; symptoms often have periods of recurrence, but no true cure has ever been observed that did not follow the law of direction.
Another law, equally applicable throughout the universe, is that of mutual action: ACTION AND REACTION ARE EQUAL AND OPPOSITE.
To some of us who have thoughtfully considered these things they seem so self-evident that it would be almost unnecessary to speak of them were it not for the purpose of urging you to observe the lawfulness of homoeopathy, and to prove our claim of the fundamental lawfulness of this true science of healing. Let us look at a law which follows naturally the law of mutual action.
This is the law designated as the law of least action, which was formulated by Maupertius, the French Mathematician.
To us as homoeopathic physicians and students it may be known as the law of quantity and dose:THE QUANTITY OF ACTION NECESSARY TO EFFECT ANY CHANGE IN NATURE IS THE LEAST POSSIBLE:THE DECISIVE AMOUNT IS ALWAYS A MINIMUM, AN INFINITESIMAL.
Health is a matter of perfect balance; trifling circumstances may sway it, and even as seemingly trifling circumstances may sway it, so may it be balanced by the least possible in medication, which may, in condition of perfect health, cause the same loss of balance, or a corresponding loss of equilibrium.
Another law of quantity to be considered here is:THE QUANTITY OF THE DRUG REQUIRED IS IN INVERSE RATION TO THE SIMILARITY. In other words, the greater the similarity of the drug symptoms to those of the patient the less quantity will be required, for the greater will be the state of susceptibility of the patient.
A corollary to the law of quantity is: THE QUALITY OF THE ACTION OF A HOMOEOPATHIC REMEDY IS DETERMINED BY ITS QUANTITY, IN INVERSE RATIO. Again this is a problem of the susceptibility of the patient and the similarity of the drug; the laws of quality and quantity go hand in hand.
Biology gives us this law:FUNCTION CREATES AND DEVELOPS THE ORGAN. It has been observed in the study of HOMOEOPATHY that functional symptoms are produced by the vital force in exact proportion to the profundity of the disturbance. Often, however, when pathological changes occur the symptomatic picture changes greatly in that functional symptoms do not manifest themselves in as great a degree; the disease condition has struck deeper and manifests itself less on the surface. Following the biological law, therefore, homoeopathy postulates the law of symptoms development:FUNCTIONAL SYMPTOMS PRECEDE STRUCTURAL CHANGES.
Now the law of use governing the homoeopathic remedy must therefore be: THE DOSE AND QUANTITY THAT WILL THOROUGHLY PERMEATE THE ORGANISM AND MAKE ITS ESSENTIAL IMPRESS UPON VITAL FORCE IS THAT WHICH WILL EFFECT THE FUNCTIONAL SPHERE OF THE INDIVIDUAL.
We say:”This must therefore be:” if we reason logically, and have observed carefully, keeping our line of reasoning along the lines of laws already formulated and proven sound, we can do no less than believe that this is truly fundamental law.
For many years daily practice has proven the value of the law of repetition of the dose;NEVER REPEAT YOUR REMEDY SO LONG AS IT CONTINUES TO ACT. This governs the administration of remedies to individuals in stages of diseases let us look at the law that must govern the production of symptoms by artificial means, i.e., drugs provings, by which we get our guidance for the administration of drugs to the sick.
The object of proving drugs is the production or artificial diseases that we may observe the symptoms and apply the substances so proven in like states of natural disturbance. The law governing this must be closely allied to the law of administration in states of diseases, or else our case is not logical. We find this law:NEVER REPEAT THE DOSE IN A PROVING WHILE SYMPTOMS ARE MANIFEST FROM THE DOSE ALREADY TAKEN.
Again granting that homoeopathy is allied to all nature, we must concede that orbits or cycles of action are fundamental part or natural manifestations. So also we find that the homoeopathic remedies have cycles of development and recession. If the natural cycle of symptom development is interfered with, we gain no knowledge of the true nature of the substance being proved; at best we can get but a distorted comprehension of its nature when there is any interference. Continuing to repeatedly administer a remedy while it is producing disease symptoms in a prover would make those out of a normal cycle of disease symptoms which have been in process of development. This is simply the result of logical reasoning.
Examining still further into laws governing the production of artificial disease states, we find there is laws governing the various states or types of substances which we desire to prove. As yet we may find these laws crudely phrased, but they follow closely the law of mutual action, the law of least action, and the laws of quantity and quality.
1.ANY DRUG WHICH IN ITS NATURAL STATE EFFECTS THE VITAL ENERGY BUT LITTLE WILL DEVELOP A PROVING ONLY IN AN HIGH POTENCY.
2.ANY DRUG WHICH IN ITS NATURAL STATE DISTURBS THE VITAL ENERGY TO FUNCTIONAL MANIFESTATIONS ONLY MAY BE PROVEN IN A CRUDE FORM.
3.ANY DRUG WHICH IN ITS NATURAL STATE DISTURBS THE VITAL ENERGY TO DESTRUCTIVE MANIFESTATIONS SHOULD BE PROVEN ONLY IN A POTENTIATED FORM.
It has been demonstrated that planetary movements have a definite relationship to life. The power of the moon over the tides is an ancient and constant observation. The relationship of the earth and the sun offers an irrefutable argument in favor of the correlation of he planetary influences. the influence of the phases of the moon on some mental conditions and nervous complaints has been noted from the earliest times.
For instance and appellation lunacy designated a mental disturbance definitely related to moon phases epileptic conditions also have shown some response to the cycles of the moon. In other words, through these abnormal conditions of mental and nervous disturbance we have perceived dimly from time to time the outlines of a great truth.
That cyclic manifestations have been demonstrated in other fields than medicine is easily seen from the most cursory glance at the science of astronomy. In its earlier states astronomy suffered from the same blind groping, ignorance and superstition that has hampered the intelligent observation of all natural phenomena;nevertheless it has emerged as a true science of mathematical exactness. It is still true that the deductions from the most careful measurements and computations very between different schools, yet it is the most closely measurable of all the sciences today.
Let us quote from The Concise Knowledge of Astronomy: History, by Agnes M. Clarke, pages 12, 13:.
The subjection of the moon to known law was completed by the dispersal of the mystery surrounding a slight, continuous acceleration of her orbital velocity detected by Halley in 1693.
It had been in progress since the earliest recorded eclipse in 721 B.C., if not longer; there was no sign of its cessation or reversal, and the grave question arose, Was the principle of universal attraction, elsewhere unreservedly obeyed, her fatally complicated by the action of a resisting medium involving the eventual collapse of the earth moon system? Laplace gave the answer in 1787 by proving the observed quickening of pace to be a necessary and simple consequence of a secular diminution in the ellipticity of the earths orbit.
This, however, will not go on forever in the same direction; after many ages the tide of change will turn, and a complete restoration to status quo ante will ensue. . . Ruinous disturbances were shown to be excluded by the overwhelming disparity of mass between the central body and its attendants, no less than by the regularity and harmony of their movements and distribution. Thus only slight oscillatory changes can occur. Millions of year will elapse without producing any fundamental alteration. The machine is so beautifully adjusted as to right itself automatically through the mutual action of its various parts. And it is the force which perturbs that eventually restores.
Let us repeat the last lines of this quotation in the light of our observation into the relation of homoeopathy and the fundamental laws: The machine is so beautifully adjusted as to right itself automatically through the mutual action of its various parts. AND IT IS THE FORCE WHICH PERTURBS THAT EVENTUALLY RESTORES.
This last observation, acknowledged by the most exact of all sciences and a deduction from observation of the most observable of all cyclic phenomena, is equally pertinent to homoeopathy and our belief in the lawful flow of vital energy. This deduction so fundamental that it might well be called a law, is closely allied to the law of mathematics; The quantity of action necessary to effect any change in nature is the least possible.
These are but a few of the laws which we, in our ignorance, have assembled from the vast resources at our command to demonstrate that homoeopathy is governed by laws that are universal, and that homoeopathy, therefore, is a part of the fundamental lawfulness and orderliness of the universe. If we can apply a known law of biology, a known law of mathematics, and a known and accepted deduction of astronomy, we can as surely apply the tested laws of any other sphere of universal activity.
At some future time we will be able to formulate definitely those laws which given the vital force and its action in the human economy. This vital energy, which is the sun of our individual human economy, has a distinct relationship to universal vital energy.
It is vital energy in the individual which offers homoeopathy its scientific demonstration of healing. Of this mystery we now comprehend but this: The state of the disordered vital energy is that state in which homoeopathy offers the greatest hope of regaining the lost balance of power in each individual, and that not by coercion of the vital force, but by so stimulating it that the equilibrium is restored by the same force that disturbed it; that the vital energy in itself is capable of disturbance and of self-restoration under the proper circumstances. We have used the laws of homoeopathy half blindly, as it were, yet we recognize their tremendous significance and their possibilities; we have observed their action in countless cases of human misery.
Let us be alert to observe and accurate to correlate the plain facts before us, that we may recognize, formulate and work in accord with the fundamental laws that govern homoeopathy and all nature.
CHAIRMAN PULFORD;This paper has quite a wide scope. I have always felt if homoeopathy couldnt be correlated with the rest of the sciences, it had better stop altogether.
DR.RAY W.SPALDING;Just to make it easier for the next one to speak, I want to say that a paper like this certainly will find added and more forceful value in its printed form. It is difficult to discuss and yet will be exceedingly helpful in reference and is, I think, one of the most progressive papers that I have heard in the Association, dealing with the fundamental laws upon which homoeopathy is based.
DR.C.A.DIXON; The thought occurs to me that this would make a mighty fine thing to have in ones library. But he has just scratched the surface, and I think Dr.Roberts should be encouraged to go in and add chapter after chapter to that, for our guidance. I like to tell my patients that the cause for disease is breaking the natural laws, and the thought occurs to me that when disease overtakes us and we apply for relief, we are just piling up more trouble for ourselves unless we adjust ourselves to natural laws.
My thought back of that is that action and reaction, as the doctor quotes, have to be equal, and if force is used to adjust disturbances which are the results of breaking natural laws, we have only chaos following.
When we are in trouble, we dont think about breaking the law. We like to take a general view of infractions along those lines. We like to think we will break the law and get by with it. Nature doesnt work that way at all. W are all amenable to these natural laws. That is the reason we become that Dame Nature keeps a ledger just like your banker does. or your business man, and after you have broken about so many laws, says: Here is an account to be settled. Come on pay up!
Well, now, the best way to pay up is to square yourself with the law again, and I dont see how force, such as is being applied by our scientific men, squares with that program at all, meaning active doses of medicine, or crude drugs, or sera, or what-have-you.
I should like to have Dr.Roberts write a paper along the same lines he started there, oh, once a month anyway, until he has nice book.
DR.GRIMMER;This is indeed a marvelous paper. the doctor has brought to out attention the relation between the mighty and the infinitesimal. Man, after all, is but a miniature universe, if you will analyze him, and, being such, is subject to the same laws that regulate these vast bodies swinging through the heavens.
Recent experiments and discoveries of the physicists have shown that everything from the minutest infinitesimal bacterium up to one of these immeasurable suns, carries proportional charges of electricity. They are electro-magnets, if you will, and that is why we are all subject to the same force; and that is why, as the doctor has stated, and that proves that his statement is true, these planetary bodies do have effect upon health and disease, upon vegetation, upon even the mighty tides of the ocean, and it is all in accordance with law.
That is the thing that should appeal to scientific men in Homoeopathy. Homoeopathy is based on law and is correlated with the universal law of cause and effect. There is no getting away from it, if you will study, as the doctor has so ably brought out here. That is why, for instance, in the Mayo clinic today they are making quite definite diagnoses by the utilization of this electric magnetic process. Some of these disease germs are put into an electric field, an electro-magnetic field, carrying one charge or another of electricity, whichever it may be. They are drawn to the electric pole for which they have affinity, and streptococci of various forms and influence and they claim they are making a most accurate diagnosis. They can see under the ultra-microscope the passage of bacterium from one pole or the other of the electro-magnetic field.
Crile, in his wonderful work on the bi-polar work of living processes, has shown man is an immense storage battery made of some twenty trillion bi-polar electric cells, each a unit and formed into systems to make up organs, and so forth, and all these systems correlated and under the dominance of the whole organism, as a whole, to perform work for the whole, and to regulate and repair itself under these same laws, and, as the doctor stated, such little thing, such as an emotional upset, or things of that kind, will overbalance and bring to a state of sometimes very severe sickness.
Now, that instrument of precision have you to measure the amount of that emotional disturbance? It is simply in a field so attenuated and so fine that there is no instrumentality to measure. We only know of its force by its effects. That is why our infinitesimal remedies-they are electrolytes of a measured, specific charge-they, floating around in the blood stream of a sick patient, go to those cells that are calling them by the electro-magnetic affinities, and when they reach those cells, there is an equilibrium established.
DR.OVERPECK:We will all go home and read this paper. who else will read it? I say that such a paper as that should be sent to every doctor in the whole country and every school, and we should give some few dollars to help do that.