Nature of the Disease – Symptoms – Pathology – Pathological Relations – Its Frequency – Prognosis – Cause of sudden death in – diagnosis – Treatment.

GENTLEMEN : Of all affections of the heart this is the most painful and distressing. While some authorities – Among whom is Dr. Watson – would place this disorder among the organic diseases, the majority consider it a functional disease. Watson thinks it is not a neuralgia, because the paroxysms are excited by bodily exertion and mental emotion, and because it is so frequently and suddenly fatal. But Dr. C. Handfield Jones disposes of this by citing the commonly observed fact that many of the neuralgiae are excited and aggravated by similar causes. Dr. Jones, after summing up the opinions of various authors, expresses himself in these words, “It is thus invariably a neuralgia, whose sole and constant seat is in the cardiac plexus.”* *On Nervous Disorders, p.212.

This affection is characterized by paroxysms of intense pain, emanating from the region of the heart, and extending in various directions, often into the left shoulder and down the arm, accompanied by indescribable anguish, a sense of suffocation, and a feeling of impending death. The pain radiates into both sides of the chest, into the back, upper extremities – generally the left – and sometimes extends into the lower extremities. The pain in the upper extremity does not always extend to the hand, sometimes it ends at the shoulder, at other times in the elbow, and the pain is occasionally felt only in the forearm. It commonly seems to follow the course of the nerves, and is felt all over the affected extremity, even to the ends of the fingers.

The pain is attended by a feeling of numbness, or as if the limb was paralyzed. A rare symptom is pain and numbness in the testicles. Hyperaesthesia, or tenderness, where the pain is felt, has been observed.

This is one of the affections that are purely paroxysmal, a strong proof of its neuralgic nature. The patient is seized suddenly, often during motion, as walking up-hill, or against a strong wind, or when quickly turning in bed.

From the first instant of attack all motion seems impossible. He seizes hold of some firm support, or fixes himself in some way immovable, until the paroxysm passes off.

Besides the pain, the feeling of suffocation alarms the patient, and he feels as if death was impending. Dyspnoea is not always present, but the breathing is often suspended for an instant, or restrained by an act of the will, for fear of increasing the pain, but the ability to expand the chest and breathe regularly is not impaired. Speaking is often impossible, or difficult, as it seems to aggravate the pain.

Palpitation is often present; the action of the heart, in some instances, intermitting and irregular; the pulse strong or feeble, and sometimes very slow. The countenance is pale and expresses terror, anxiety, and distress; a death-like complexion and haggard features suddenly taking the place of an appearance of health. Lividity is sometimes observed. The surface is cold and bathed in cold sweat. The faculties of the mind remain unaffected or nearly so. After an attack a sense of prostration is present, and sometimes, as after other nervous attacks, a free secretion of pale limpid urine.

The paroxysms differ in the frequency of their occurrence, duration, severity, etc.

They may recur every few hours, days, or weeks, and often years may elapse between them. They are sometimes very mild at first, and afterwards increase in severity; or the first may be very severe. They may last for a few moments or seconds, or continue several hours. They will often subside as suddenly as they commenced; at other times the relief is gradual.

You must not get the idea that they only occur after some physical or mental excitement, for they often occur at night, during sleep. I have known persons who were thus affected, rendered so fearful of going to sleep as to make life almost insupportable. In one case a fearful dream seemed to the patient to be the exciting cause.

You will naturally inquire what is the pathological character of this affection, also its pathological relations. As I have said, I believe the affection is generally a form of neuralgia. The character of the pain proves this. It has been ascribed to spasm, but a spasm of the heart, lasting as long as an ordinary paroxysm of angina, would destroy life; besides, the heart’s action is seldom, if ever, arrested.

The pathological relations of angina are interesting. Flint says, “It involves, in a large proportion of cases, the existence of some organic affection of the heart and aorta,” and adds that the lesions found “do not agree invariably in any appreciable morbid alternations.” Valvular lesions may be present or wanting. Calcification of the coronary arteries is sometimes present. Fatty degeneration has been observed. It has been asserted that a “weakened heart” is essential to the presence of the disorder, but this theory is disputed by both Flint and Jones. While I do not believe that a weak heart is a necessary condition, it is more than probable that a condition is often present which is similar to myalgia elsewhere in the body. In other words, cardiac myalgia may stimulate, or coexist with, angina.

As before remarked, angina pectoris is a very rare affection. In 338 cases of organic disease of the heart, Flint found it to exist in 15 only. That it occurs more frequently with than without organic disease seems proven.

The causes of this disorder are at best obscure. It has been supposed to arise from the rheumatic or gouty diathesis, but this supposition is not tenable. Nor can it be said to arise from dyspepsia. Trousseau considers angina a form of epilepsy, but this seems to me only a fanciful idea.

It occurs much oftener in males than in females, and in the majority of cases occurs after the age of fifty. But cases have been observed in youth, and even in infancy.


The prognosis will depend largely on the condition of the heart. If that organ, or the aorta, is in a state of structural disease, the prognosis is far more unfavorable than if the disorder is purely functional in character. If organic disease is present, you cannot assure the patient of exemption from their recurrence, while, if not connected with lesions, years may elapse before another paroxysm occurs.

Paroxysms of angina sometimes cause sudden death. In such instances, “the action of the heart is arrested by a morbid agency affecting it through the pneumogastric nerves, in the manner in which irritation of these nerves, or the electrical currents, produces this effect in experimental observations.” (Flint.)

The danger is in proportion as the action of the heart is feeble, irregular, or retarded during the paroxysm. But if the action of the heart be but little, or not at all disturbed during the paroxysm, there will be but small danger of sudden death. Sudden death will oftener occur when organic disease is present, than when the disorder is purely functional. Even if organic disease is present, judicious homoeopathic treatment often cures, and generally cures the purely neuralgic.

The diagnosis of this disease is generally easy. I do not see how the paroxysms can be confounded with attacks of dyspnoea, or so-called cardiac asthma, for with the latter motion is not incompatible, pain is rarely present, they do not occur abruptly, and there is not the same fear of impending death.

There is a pseudo angina occurring in hysterical, anaemic, or dyspeptic persons. The misnamed cardialgia may sometimes simulate angina, and I have known the pain under the left breast, occurring in women, to be so severe as to resemble that disorder. Intercostal neuralgia and myalgia may closely imitate it; but the tenderness on pressure, which is so diagnostic of the former, is rarely present in angina pectoris.


The treatment of this distressing disorder embraces: 1. Remedies which will diminish the severity and shorten the duration of the paroxysms.

2. Such treatment in the intervals as will postpone or prevent the recurrence of the paroxysms.

It is a difficult matter, as you will find, to treat a single paroxysm. It is generally of such short duration that no remedy can be selected and given before the brief “reign of terror” is over.

But in those instances in which the paroxysm is of longer duration, you should do your best to allay the terrible distress. A firm and reliant demeanor on your part – assuring the patient that he will not die – is of much service, for the deadly fear, added to the pain, may be a source of danger to the patient. There is some reliable testimony that a dose of arsenicum, 30th, has shortened the paroxysm. The same has been asserted of lachesis, 30th.

Certainly these remedies, if any, will act with sufficient rapidity, and are generally indicated in the severer forms.

If the action of the heart is very irregular and feeble, and there is a tendency to, or actual fainting, you should resort to the diffusible stimulants, such as brandy, or any kind of spirits which you can immediately procure, or, what is sometimes better, ammonium carb., a few grains, dissolved in milk and water. A prompt resort to stimulants may save the patient’s life, and ward off sudden and fatal syncope and cardiac paralysis.

Edwin Hale
Edwin Moses Hale 1829 – 1899 was an orthodox doctor who converted to homeopathy graduated at the Cleveland Homoeopathic Medical College to become Professor Emeritus of Materia Medica and Therapeutics at Hahnemann Medical College, editor of the North American Journal of Homeopathy and The American Homeopathic Observer and a member of the American Institute of Homeopathy. Hale was also a member of The Chicago Literary Club.

Hale wrote Lectures On Diseases Of The Heart, Materia medica and special therapeutics of the new remedies Volume 1, Materia Medica And Special Therapeutics Of The New Remedies Volume 2, Saw Palmetto: (Sabal Serrulata. Serenoa Serrulata), The Medical, Surgical, and Hygienic Treatment of Diseases of Women, New Remedies: Their Pathogenetic Effects and Therapeutic Application, Ilex Cassine : the aboriginal North American tea, Repertory to the New Remedies with Charles Porter Hart, The Characteristics of the New Remedies, Materia Medica and Special Therapeutics of the New Remedies, The Practice of Medicine, Homoeopathic Materia Medica of the New Remedies: Their Botanical Description etc.