The febrile symptoms brought on during a Camphor reaction are very marked, and typhoid in appearance; and so are the cerebral symptoms occurring at the stage of cholera-reaction. Hahnemann actually has put on record the great benefit he derived from the administration of Camphor, in a prevailing type of intermittent fever. Yet who ever thinks of administering Camphor at the febrile cholera reaction? I have shown before, that Cuprum has no less typhoid fever amongst its pathogenesis;the cerebral irritation it causes, is well-known in our school, not to be attended by any traces of inflammation; but it seems that there prevails a common and most erroneous impression, that remedies suited for the cold stage of cholera could no more be suitable to the opposite stage of febrile reaction. So long as the reactionary fever was in itself a sort of salutary transition from disease to health, it did not matter much how the patient was treated at that stage. When the fever constitutes, however, as it has been of late the case, a pathological disorder of its own–in fact the final issue of cholera; then none but the properly selected homeopathic remedies can be of any help, and they can certainly not lie far away from the range of cholera similars. Again some wise acres of practitioners would fly to the administration of Cina, never mind what may be the matter with the patient, as soon as they discover that the patient bores at his nose. Let them remember that Veratrum has also that symptom.

Of non-choleraic fever remedies, Rhus Toxicodendron and Phosphoric Acid have always maintained a reputation as beneficial in the reactionary fever. Bryonia and Baptisia are very rarely of much use; there is, however, no saying what may or may not be indicated in a certain case or epidemic, for each such case or epidemic must be treated on its individual merits. The febrile condition calling for Rhus is usually associated with restlessness, while dullness and apathy characterise the Phosphoric Acid patient. The indications for Veratrum, Cuprum, Secale and Camphor have been given in the course of these lectures. Colchicum may be called for in typhoid conditions with great tympany, body hot, extremities cold, stools flaky.

Local complications require specific organic remedies. Phosphorus, Tartar Emet., Carbolic Acid, in congestion of the lungs. Cuprum, Nux Vomica, Arsenic (high dilution), Ipecac, in gastric irritation. Excessive acidity we try to combat by Nux Vom., Calcarea Carb., Calcarea Arsenicum, Robinia, Carbo Veg., Lycopod., iris Vers., or Eupatorium Perfol. And last, though by no means least, Strychninum Arsenicosum should be thought of in all cases of extreme gastric irritation and rejection of anything taken, during the reactionary stage. I have found it successful when all other remedies failed. This excessive acidity is the consequence of a reactionary process. The choleraic evacuations being alkaline we may consider cholera at an end with the advent of acidity, in the stools or in the vomit. Nevertheless it would be unwise to leave the patient without further medical assistance the moment such acidity makes itself felt, subjectively or objectively. Experience teaches that reaction in excess is just as dangerous to life as the original disease. If my plan, as suggested before, is to be carried out in practice and Kali Arsenicum is to be given during the whole cholera process, where we now are in the habit of giving Arsenic, then Arsenic (which means Arsenious Acid) might be given from the moment acidity makes itself felt, I say again, subjectively or objectively, as shown by test-paper (Comp. pp. 122-123). Cantharides, Terebinthina, Carbolic Acid and last, but by no means least, Camphor, in congestions of the urinary apparatus. Nausea after drinking water with or without sour vomiting reminds one of Natr. Carb which should be superior to Nux Vom. usually given in such cases. Fetid stools often call for Psorinum, and so on. Retention of urine with a full bladder causes often great restlessness. The catheter may be applied in such cases; Camphor externally and internally, Cantharides and, last but not least, Petrosel. Cerebral congestion may require Hyoscyam., Cuprum. Camphor, and Cantharides. Cerebral paralysis, not associated with come : Lycop., Zincum met., Zincum Phosph and Baryta Mur. When associated with comma : Arsenic, Opium and Chloral. With hydrocephaloid symptoms : Helleb., Calcarea phos. and China. For all particular indication for the right and proper use of these medicines I must refer you to our standard works on Materia Medica and Pharmaco-dynamics. For the diarrhoea occurring at the febrile stage I have found either China, Phosphorus, Croton Tiglium, Podophyl., Mercury or Mercurius Sulph. most frequently indicated.

China. more or less flatulence or extreme tympanitic distention of the abdomen; stools painless; yellow, liquid, sometimes fetid, liable to come on after eating or drinking; tongue coated, white or yellow, bitter taste : extreme weakness; coldness of the prominent parts of the face, nose, ears, cheeks.

The diarrhoeic stools of Phosphorus and Croton have been described before.

Mercurius. Stools green, watery, slimy, with or without blood-streaks. (Let it be remembered that Terebintha has watery slimy stools). Bad smell from the mouth; region of liver painful to contact; presence or absence of tenesmus.

Mercurius Sulph. Stools of the same consistency as the cholera stools (rice-water stools) but yellow.

Gratiola. Yellow stools, persisting yellow vomiting, excessive thirst, which appears to complicate the gastric disorders.

Lastly I would remind you of Oleum Ricini which might find a place in some cases of diarrhoea, not coming under the above designations.

It is bad practice to alternate remedies in this stage. The remedy should be so selected that it suits both the fever and the diarrhoea.

Stools resembling bloody serum, point to Rhus Tox., Ricinus., Phosphorus; dysenteric stools, to Cantharis, Mercurius Corrosivus; haemorrhage from the bowels to Carbo Veget; discharge of black, liquid blood to Elaps., Arsen-Hydrogenis. This latter drug has bloody stools with scrapings, or stools like flesh water, with scrapings. Such stools occur often at the end of the rice-water stools, just about the time when reaction is to set in; there is congestion towards the pelvic region with burning in the urethra and tenesmus–all this points to Cantharis; the scrapings distinguish the Cantharides from the Mercurius Cor. stools.

I would particularly draw your attention to the following statement of Dr. Macnamara which has but too frequently been verified in practice. Another complication incident to the stage of reaction, which seems to me more common amongst the natives of this country than among Europeans, is the formation of a clot in the right side of the heart, usually extending into the pulmonary arteries. The patient seems to be doing well, when, suddenly, difficulty of breathing comes on, followed by collapse and death. I have seen more instances of this kind during the present season (1869) than I remember on any former occasion, and they render one extremely cautious in giving a prognosis, even in cases which, to all appearance, are doing remarkably well.

The nature of this most unpleasant incidence is so, that we can hardly provide against it. Dr. Buchner states that Calcarea Arsenicosa prevents the formation of coagula. I cannot say by what mode of reasoning, or by what sort of clinical experience he arrived at that conclusion. The formation of a clot in cases of cholera is not owing to formation of coagula, the fibrin being in all cholera cases conspicuous by their absence; it is owing to a fusing together of the red blood corpuscles, because they have lost their corpuscular structure and power of coagulation. I have, however, taken the hint, and found that Calcarea Arsenicosa 6th to 12th is certainly an excellent restorative in the asthenic sequelae of cholera.

In this season (1886-87) death in consequence of embolism is very frequent. Formerly we heard it exceedingly seldom that a cholera patient died suddenly but now half of them, I should say, die in this manner. The patient is apparently doing well, vomiting and purging have just ceased, or are about to cease; he gets somewhat warmer and is quiet; we should expect a gradual reaction, while all of a sudden the patient gasps his last, or he turns to his right or left side, and is thought to fall asleep.

While he is, to the surprise of those around him, found dead.

Are we, at such a season, to administer Calcarea Arsenicum when the urgent symptoms of vomiting and purging subside, as a sort of prophylactic? Are we to pin our faith to Calcarea Arsenicum to the exclusion of all other remedies, along the whole cholera treatment? These are two important questions, which can only be answered by a third one : What has clinical experience to say to all these suggestions?

Terebinthina is said to be a coagulator of blood, so are the Salts of Iron. Should we employ Ferrum Arsenicosum? Should we administer Terebintha in cases where it is considered advisable to do something to bring on the secretion of urine? Lastly we should not forget Ammonium Carb. which is said in Allen’s Hand Book of Materia Medica and Therapeutics to be useful in cases of a threatening clot-forming at the heart. Ammon Carb. is, however, known to be a solvent of fibrine, at least in its primary action. Are we then to apply it in large doses on allopathic principles?.

Leopold Salzer
Leopold Salzer, MD, lived in Calcutta, India. Author of Lectures on Cholera and Its Homeopathic Treatment (1883)